Backtesting

How the rules would have performed from January 2009 to November 2026 — through the euro crisis, the 2018 sell-off, the Covid crash and the 2022 bear market.

Annualized return
22.47%
vs. 14.64% S&P 500
Total return
3,645.55%
vs. 1,048.94% S&P 500
Sharpe ratio
1.22
risk-adjusted
Max drawdown
-33.55%
vs. -33.72% S&P 500

The Small Edge vs. S&P 500

January 2009 – November 2026 · $100 invested

Performance summary

MetricStrategyS&P 500
PeriodJan 2009 – Nov 2026Jan 2009 – Nov 2026
Annualized return22.47%14.64%
Total return3,645.55%1,048.94%
Active return2,596.62%—
Sharpe ratio1.22—
Max drawdown-33.55%-33.72%
Winning positions55.00% (172/311)—
Annual turnover74.57%—
Correlation with S&P 5000.781.00
Positions~20—
Position sizingEqual weight—
RebalancingWeekly—
UniverseEurope, Canada, USA—
Buy rule: market cap$10M – $2,000M—
Buy rule: liquidityAvg. daily traded > $30,000 (20 days)—
SlippageVariable, 0.08% – 4.00%, depending on the stock's liquidity—

Calendar-year returns

Beat the S&P 500 in 13 of 17 full years
YearStrategyS&P 500Difference
2009+55.9%+26.4%+29.5%
2010+20.6%+15.1%+5.5%
2011+0.8%+1.9%-1.1%
2012+31.3%+16.0%+15.3%
2013+49.3%+32.3%+17.0%
2014+10.3%+13.5%-3.2%
2015+19.0%+1.2%+17.8%
2016+20.5%+12.0%+8.5%
2017+24.9%+21.7%+3.2%
2018-8.6%-4.6%-4.0%
2019+32.5%+31.2%+1.3%
2020+41.1%+18.3%+22.8%
2021+30.8%+28.7%+2.1%
2022-15.3%-18.2%+2.9%
2023+24.6%+26.2%-1.6%
2024+36.0%+24.9%+11.1%
2025+51.1%+17.7%+33.4%
2026 (YTD)+5.3%+11.5%-6.2%

The strategy

The ranking system asks six questions about every stock and turns the answers into one score from 0 to 100. Each family is built from several factors, measured over short and long periods, so no single number can dominate. The weights below decide how much each question counts.

  • Quality30%
  • Value25%
  • Growth15%
  • Low volatility10%
  • Sentiment10%
  • Momentum10%

Quality

30%

Is this a good business?

Margins, asset turnover, return on capital and balance-sheet strength, mostly measured against industry peers and averaged over five years.

MarginsAsset turnoverReturn on capitalFinances

Value

25%

Is it cheap?

Price against earnings, sales, free cash flow and assets, using both trailing figures and analyst forecasts.

EarningsSalesFree cash flowAssets

Growth

15%

Is it growing, and faster than before?

Growth in earnings, sales and operating income over one quarter, one year and five years, plus whether that growth is accelerating.

EPS growthSales growthOperating income growthAcceleration

Low volatility

10%

Is it calm?

Lower beta and lower price volatility over one, three and five years score better.

BetaPrice volatility

Sentiment

10%

Are expectations improving?

Upward estimate revisions, positive earnings surprises, improving analyst recommendations and low short interest.

Estimate revisionsEarnings surprisesRecommendationsShort interest

Momentum

10%

Is the market starting to notice?

Six- to nine-month price strength, steady up-days, consistent quarterly returns and a strong industry.

Price changeUp/down ratioQuarterly returnsIndustry momentum
Read the full breakdown: inside the ranking system

How to invest by the rules

The rules are simple enough to follow by hand: buy the top, hold while the rank stays high, sell when it drops below 95, and start again with the next best stock. The screener marks every stock below 95 in red, and your portfolio shows a sell recommendation for it.

1009590HOLD ZONE · rank ≥ 95SELL ZONE · rank < 95BuySellBuy nextweeks →
Illustration, not real data. The dark line is a stock bought at the top of the ranking and held while its rank stays at 95 or higher. When it slips below 95 it is sold and the money goes into the best-ranked stock not yet owned (orange).
  1. STEP 1

    Buy the top

    Buy the highest-ranked stocks in the screener, about 20 positions, equally weighted.

  2. STEP 2

    Hold while rank ≥ 95

    Check the ranks once a week. As long as a stock ranks 95 or higher, do nothing.

  3. STEP 3

    Sell below 95, then repeat

    When the rank drops below 95 (or the stock leaves the screen), sell it and buy the best-ranked stock you don't own yet.

Methodology

Investment universe

Primary listings of small and micro-cap companies in Europe, Canada and the USA. A stock can only be bought if its market cap is between $10 million and $2 billion and it trades more than $30,000 a day on average over the last 20 days. This segment is thinly covered by analysts, which leaves room for persistent mispricing.

Ranking, not opinions

Every stock is scored by a multi-factor ranking system built from six factor families (see above). Only the top-ranked names enter the portfolio. No stock is picked because of a story.

Rebalancing & sizing

The model holds around 20 equally weighted positions and is rebalanced once a week. A stock is sold when its rank drops below 95 and replaced by the best-ranked stock not yet held.

Point-in-time data

The simulation runs on Portfolio123 with point-in-time data: each week only uses information that was actually available on that date. Preliminary figures are excluded to avoid look-ahead bias.

Transaction costs

Small caps are harder to trade than large caps: spreads are wider and big orders move the price. A flat cost assumption would flatter the least liquid stocks — exactly the ones a small-cap strategy tends to buy.

The backtest therefore applies variable slippageto every trade, based on each stock's liquidity (10-day average daily amount traded, volume × price). The thinner the stock, the higher the cost — up to 4% per trade for the least liquid names. All returns shown on this page are after these costs.

Daily liquiditySlippage per trade
Up to $40,0004.00%
$40,001 – $55,0003.00%
$55,001 – $80,0002.00%
$80,001 – $125,0001.25%
$125,001 – $225,0000.80%
$225,001 – $450,0000.50%
$450,001 – $900,0000.30%
$900,001 – $2,000,0000.20%
$2,000,001 – $7,500,0000.12%
Over $7,500,0000.08%

Reading these results honestly

The strategy did not win every year. It lagged the S&P 500 in 4 of 17 full years and went through a drawdown of -33.55% — roughly the same depth as the index. Sticking to the rules through those stretches is exactly where the edge comes from.

With an annual turnover of 74.57%, the average position is held for more than a year. The variable slippage model accounts for each stock's liquidity, but your real execution costs still depend on your broker, order type and position size.

Simulated results on Portfolio123. Past performance — simulated or real — is not indicative of future results. This is not investment advice.

Follow the rules each week

Get the daily-updated ranking, clear sell signals and your own portfolio tracker.

See pricing